Researched by the Inspire21 editors from the sources listed at the end. About our story labels
On Thanksgiving Day 1942, the family cook, Mrs. Thaddeus Wheaton, presented the turkey in Norman Rockwell’s living room in Arlington, Vermont, and Rockwell photographed her. He later said he painted the turkey that very day.
That turkey sits at the center of “Freedom from Want.” Nine years later, the Post ran a second Rockwell Thanksgiving picture, “Saying Grace.” One shows a family table full of food. The other shows a woman and a boy praying in public while others look on. Both were built from the faces of ordinary people.
An Idea Nobody Wanted
Rockwell painted more than 320 covers for The Saturday Evening Post. But the paintings behind “Freedom from Want” began with a door that closed.
In his 1941 State of the Union address, President Franklin D. Roosevelt named four freedoms: freedom of speech, freedom of worship, freedom from want and freedom from fear. Rockwell offered to paint all four. Government officials turned him down. Undersecretary of War Robert Patterson told him they didn’t have time to arrange it.
On the train home, Rockwell stopped in Philadelphia to see Ben Hibbs, his new editor at the Post. Hibbs embraced the idea. Rockwell was given eight weeks to finish the series. It took him seven months.
The Neighbors Around the Table
Rockwell painted “Freedom from Want” in November 1942. The setting was his own living room, and the people were his friends, family and neighbors in Arlington.
Mrs. Wheaton posed as the grandmother serving the turkey, and she really did cook it. Her husband stands beside her. Around the table sit Lester Brush, Florence Lindsey, Rockwell’s mother Nancy, Jim Martin, Dan Walsh, Rockwell’s wife Mary, Charles Lindsey, and two children, Bill and Shirley Hoisington. Shirley, at the end of the table, was six years old.
They look as if they are all sharing one happy meal. In fact, each person was photographed alone and painted in one at a time. They never sat at that table together.
Rockwell said it was the easiest of the four paintings. It is admired for one hard part: white plates on a white tablecloth.
The Post ran the four paintings on four weeks in a row in 1943. “Freedom from Want” appeared on March 6, alongside an essay by the writer Carlos Bulosan. Over the years the picture picked up other names, too: “The Thanksgiving Picture” and “I’ll Be Home for Christmas.”
Paintings That Went to Work
Within days, the government that had turned Rockwell away took up his paintings to sell War Bonds. The four originals toured 16 cities, often with Rockwell there signing posters. They brought in about $132 million in bond sales.
For years afterward, the four paintings hung in the Old Corner House on Main Street in Stockbridge, Massachusetts. When the Norman Rockwell Museum opened in 1993, they moved there.
A Letter From a Reader
Post readers sent Rockwell a great many ideas for covers. He almost never used them. “Saying Grace” was one of the rare times he did.
On November 27, 1950, a reader with the last name Earl, of Upper Darby, Pennsylvania, wrote a letter. The letter described a Mennonite family praying in a Horn & Hardart automat.
According to the letter, a “plain” young woman and a boy of about five sat down at a table where two men were already eating. The two folded their hands, bowed their heads and said grace for two minutes.
Rockwell had photographs taken inside an automat in New York City and of a street scene in Albany. Then he made the story his own. He moved it from the automat to a shabby railroad restaurant, and he painted an older woman praying with the boy while others look on.
Once again, his neighbors stepped in. An Arlington boy named Donald F. Hubert Jr. posed as the child. Years later, in a 1986 letter, he recalled that he couldn’t keep his feet still, so someone taped his ankles together for the photo session. Rockwell’s student apprentice, Don Winslow, posed as the man with the cigarette. Rockwell’s son Jarvis posed as one of the young men watching.
“Saying Grace” was the cover of the Post’s Thanksgiving issue on November 24, 1951, almost exactly a year after the letter was written.
Why It Still Matters
In 1955, Post readers voted “Saying Grace” their favorite cover ever. Rockwell gave the painting to his friend Kenneth J. Stuart, the Post’s art director. It hung in Stuart’s office and later in the family’s home in Wilton, Connecticut.
The painting is about something simple. A woman and a boy stop in a shabby railroad restaurant to bow their heads and give thanks for their food, while others look on.
Neither painting shows a famous person. They show a cook, a mother, a wife, neighbors, children and a boy who couldn’t keep his feet still. A stranger’s two-minute prayer, noticed by one reader, became the cover Post readers loved most.
Is It True?
“The whole family really sat down to that dinner together.” Not quite. The turkey was real, and so was the cook who cooked it on Thanksgiving Day 1942. But each person in “Freedom from Want” was photographed alone and painted in separately.
“Freedom from Want was painted in 1943.” It was published in 1943, but Rockwell painted it in November 1942.
“Saying Grace shows exactly what the reader saw in the automat.” The reader’s letter described a young woman and a boy of about five in an automat. Rockwell painted an older woman instead and moved the scene to a railroad restaurant.
A Lesson for Today
- Rockwell’s idea was turned down, and a stop on the way home changed everything. A closed door is not always the last door.
- A woman and a boy said grace for two minutes in an automat, and a stranger wrote a letter about it. Our quiet faith is often seen by more people than we know.
- The faces in these paintings belonged to ordinary neighbors. This Thanksgiving, look around your own table and give thanks for the ordinary people God has placed there.
Sources
- Freedom from Want – Wikipedia
- Norman Rockwell's "Four Freedoms" – Museum of Fine Arts, Houston
- Storeroom Stories: Freedom from Want – The Charleston Museum
- Four Freedoms: Paintings that Inspired a Nation – Antiques and the Arts Weekly
- Saying Grace – Norman Rockwell Museum Audio Tour
- Saying Grace Signed Print – Norman Rockwell Museum Store
- Norman Rockwell, Saying Grace (Lot 10) – Sotheby's 2013 catalog
- Saying Grace (Rockwell) – Wikipedia
From inspire21.com/a-turkey-a-prayer-and-a-letter-rockwells-thanksgiving-paintings/
More like this in Thanksgiving Stories.
Did this story lift you up?
Share it with someone
Up next

How to Explain God
One of God’s main jobs is making people. He makes them to replace the ones that die so there will be enough people to take care of things on earth. He…



