Watercolor of a snowy New England church steeple with its bell at dusk and a candle glowing in a nearby window.

Bells of Hope: The True Story Behind "I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day"

Real-life story7 min read

Illustration

Researched by the Inspire21 editors from the sources listed at the end. About our story labels

Every December, choirs and congregations sing a carol about bells ringing out “peace on earth, good-will to men.” Few of the singers know that the words came from a man who, for a time, found no joy in Christmas at all.

On Christmas Day 1861, the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow wrote in his journal: “How inexpressibly sad are all holidays!” Less than six months earlier, he had lost his wife.

Henry and Fanny Longfellow (she was born Frances Elizabeth Appleton) made their home in Cambridge, Massachusetts. They had five children who grew up: Charles, Ernest, Alice, Edith and Anne. Another little daughter, also named Fanny, had died a few months after her first birthday.

On the afternoon of July 9, 1861, Fanny’s light dress caught fire, and she was covered in flames. No one knows exactly how it started. She may have touched her dress to a candle she was using to melt sealing wax, or she may have stepped on a match. Henry burned his hands and face trying to put out the flames.

Fanny died the next morning, July 10, 1861, in the bedroom now called the “Gold Ring Room.” Henry’s burns were so bad that he could not go to her funeral on July 13. That day would have been their 18th wedding anniversary. She was buried in Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge.

Afterward, a chalk portrait of Fanny, drawn by Samuel Rowse in 1859, was hung in that bedroom. It still hangs there today, across from Longfellow’s bed.

The poet who had filled so many pages now wrote far fewer poems of his own. For several years he worked mostly on translating Dante’s Divine Comedy.

The same year Fanny died, 1861, the Civil War began. And soon the war came to the Longfellow house.

In March 1863, his oldest son, Charley, ran away to join the Union Army. His father learned about it from a letter Charley wrote after he had already gone. Charley first enlisted as a private in Battery A, 1st Massachusetts Artillery. Later he became a lieutenant in the 1st Massachusetts Cavalry. In October 1863 he and his friend Lt. Daniel Henry Lawrence Gleason were photographed together in Culpeper, Virginia.

Then, on November 27, 1863, at New Hope Church, Virginia, during the Mine Run Campaign, Charley was shot. In his war journal he wrote simply: “Got pluged.” The bullet went in at his left shoulder, crossed his back near the spine and came out under his right shoulder blade.

On December 1, Longfellow was at dinner when a telegram arrived about the wound. He left for Washington at once, and his younger son Ernest went with him. They arrived on December 3. By December 8, Charley was home in Cambridge to recover. The wound was too serious for him to go back to his unit, and in February 1864 he was honorably discharged.

Looking back on those weeks, Longfellow told a friend, “I have been through a great deal of trouble and anxiety.”

The war, though, went on. According to the National Park Service, which cares for Longfellow’s house today, he had been working out phrases about the war long before he sat down to write. The official annotated edition of his poems dates the finished poem to December 25, 1864. He called it “Christmas Bells.”

The poem has seven stanzas. Two of them speak of the cannon “in the South” and of an “earthquake” tearing apart “the hearth-stones of a continent.”

And then comes the honest heart of the poem. The poet bows his head in despair and says there is no peace on earth, “For hate is strong, / And mocks the song.” But the bells will not be quiet. They peal “more loud and deep” with an answer: “God is not dead, nor doth He sleep.”

The poem was first published in February 1865 in Our Young Folks, a magazine for children. It later appeared in his book Flower-de-Luce.

In 1872 an English organist, John Baptiste Calkin, set the words to music, and the poem began its new life as a carol. It became especially popular in the 1950s, when Bing Crosby recorded an arrangement by songwriter Johnny Marks. Over the years it has been sung by Elvis Presley, Johnny Cash, Harry Belafonte, the Carpenters and the Mormon Tabernacle Choir, among many others. Today “Christmas Bells” is probably Longfellow’s best-known poem after “Paul Revere’s Ride.”

Most versions we sing today leave out the two stanzas about the war. But knowing they are there helps us hear the carol the way it was written: not as a cheerful jingle, but as a hard-won answer to grief.

Longfellow did not pretend his sorrow away. Years later he was still writing about Fanny. But on Christmas Day 1864, a year after his son’s wound, with the war still raging and an empty place at his side, he set down the words that so many people have sung ever since: “The Wrong shall fail, / The Right prevail.”

As for Charley, the young soldier whose wound brought his father to Washington, he went on to become a world traveler and an author.

Is It True?

“Longfellow wrote it on Christmas Day 1863, while caring for his wounded son.” This is told very often, but the National Park Service says he wrote the poem in 1864, and the official annotated edition of his works dates it December 25, 1864. Charley was wounded in late 1863. A year later, on Christmas Day 1864, with the war still going on, Longfellow wrote “Christmas Bells.”

“Charley was left paralyzed for life.” An army surgeon did warn that “paralysis might ensue,” but Charley recovered well enough to travel the world. He did not go back to the war and was discharged in February 1864.

“Longfellow wrote the carol.” He wrote a poem called “Christmas Bells.” Others set it to music: John Baptiste Calkin in 1872, and later Johnny Marks in the 1950s. The usual carol leaves out the poem’s two war stanzas.

“Fanny died while sealing an envelope with wax.” This is often told as fact, but the exact cause of the fire is unclear. It may have been a candle she was using to melt sealing wax, or a match she stepped on.

In His Own Words

In a letter written a month after Fanny’s death, Longfellow described what she had meant to him:

“she never came into a room where I was without my heart beating quicker, nor went out without my feeling that something of the light went with her.”

In his journal in December 1862, the second Christmas without her:

“‘A merry Christmas’ say the children, but that is no more for me.”

The turning point and closing lines of “Christmas Bells”:

“And in despair I bowed my head;
‘There is no peace on earth,’ I said;
‘For hate is strong,
And mocks the song
Of peace on earth, good-will to men!’
Then pealed the bells more loud and deep:
‘God is not dead, nor doth He sleep;
The Wrong shall fail,
The Right prevail,
With peace on earth, good-will to men.’”

From “The Cross of Snow,” a sonnet he wrote in 1879, eighteen years after Fanny died, and never published:

“Such is the cross I wear upon my breast / These eighteen years, through all the changing scenes / And seasons, changeless since the day she died.”

A Lesson for Today

Longfellow’s poem gives us permission to be honest about sorrow. He said out loud, “There is no peace on earth”—and then he kept listening until he heard the bells again. For anyone facing a hard Christmas this year, the carol is a reminder that hope does not mean pretending; it means holding on to the promise that “God is not dead, nor doth He sleep.”

Sources

Reading this aloud?

Good for
An Advent sermon, a Christmas program at a senior center or a grief support group in December
Time
About 9 minutes read aloud
Fits a lesson on
hope in grief, Christmas, trusting God, honesty about sorrow

Tip: Slow down for the stanza beginning "And in despair I bowed my head," pause after "mocks the song," then read "God is not dead, nor doth He sleep" a little louder, like the bells.

Questions to talk about

  1. Why do you think Longfellow found holidays so hard after losing Fanny?
  2. How does knowing the story behind the carol change the way you hear it?
  3. When have you felt like saying "there is no peace on earth," and what helped you hear the bells again?
  4. What could we do this Christmas for someone facing a hard season?

Lead a group every week? Get the free large-print Read-Aloud Pack, four stories with questions and memory care prompts, ready to print.

More like this in Christmas stories.

Did this story lift you up?

Share it with someone

Real-life story

Inspire21 Editors

Researched and written by the Inspire21 editors, with AI assistance, and checked against the sources listed above.

Up next

Holidays

Ask Any Soldier

T his uplifting message is all about AnySoldier.com ... an online service that helps people who want to send care packages to American troops stationed…

From the archiveInspire21 archive3 min

More holidays stories

See all